Monday, April 2, 2012

Frozen Butterfinger Pie

Oh my, OH my, O.H. M.Y.!!!!

I have just found heaven.

Not kidding at all!!

I've told you before that I love candy bars so when I saw a recipe for this beauty I knew I had to try it especially because my 9 year old loves Butterfingers probably more than I do.

This was amazing.  We all loved it and it is definitely a keeper and will be made over and over again.  My brother and his wife was visiting and we convinced them to have some because we just couldn't have it around anymore.  This sat in the freezer and called to me the entire time--it took all my self control to not eat more 3 pieces.

Sad I know but so very true!  So do yourself a favor and make you tummy some and it will love you forever.

Frozen Butterfinger Pie

(click here for printable version)

Chocolate or Oreo pre-made Crust
8 oz block cream cheese, softened
1/2 of a 14 oz can of sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup peanut butter
1/4 cup powdered sugar
8 oz tub Cool Whip, thawed
3 full size Butterfinger candy bars, chopped coarsely

1.  In the bowl of a mixer, combine cream cheese, condensed milk, peanut butter, and powdered sugar.  Beat on medium until smooth and completely combined, about 1-2 minutes

2.  Using a rubber spatula, fold in the Cool Whip until combined.  Add chopped candy and fold again until distributed evenly.

3.  Pour mixture into pie crust.  Cover and freeze until firm, about 3-4 hours.  Serve with additional chopped candy bars and whipped cream if wanted.  Enjoy!!

Source: Confessions of a Cookbook Queen


Mama Jodi said...

OK - my husband would die for this. It's on my to do list for him. Thanks for sharing your recipe. Jodi @

Maria said...

Oh my goodness this looks and sounds SO GOOD!!!! Butterfinger pie!?!? YUM!!!!!

Kate @ craftwhatever said...

Wow, does this look like a good idea! I love Butterfingers!

Sarahsworld said...

Hi! I saw your link on Adventure of a DIY mom. Thanks for ruining my diet ;) I'm pinning this!

Patsy said...

Oh, how I love Butterfinger candy bars!!! I saw this on What's New Wednesday, and just had to get this recipe! I am a new follower. Patsy

cupsbykim said...

No kidding this is heaven!! This looks so good!! I'd love for you to share it at Sweet & Simple Sunday!!


Jill @Two Yellow Birds Decor said...

All I have to say is YUM!!!!! Oh this sounds and looks AMAZING! I love butterfingers. I am so making this soon!! Thanks so much for sharing at Thursday's Temptation.

Alyssa said...

Oh wow this looks so good!! I could really go for a piece right now.

I would love if you would share this and any other posts at my new link party:
Thanks and hope to see you there!

Julie E said...

This pie looks freakin' amazing! I L-O-V-E butterfingers. So adding this to my Make Me Now list.

I'd love for you to share at my link party. :)

Rachel said...

This looks soooo yummy! Pinned! Thanks for sharing at Terrific Tuesdays.

keri @ shaken together said...

This looks {amazing}!! And I featured you today over at my place ... via {wow me wednesday} with Ginger Snap Crafts :)

Taylor said...

One of my favorite candies! I would love for you to share this with my Unveil Your Genius Link Party! (New linky every Thursday). Here's this week's linky link:

Happy Friday!

Heather Green said...

Whoa. That looks phenomenal. I will be making this! :) said...

Hi, I'm featuring this at What's New Wednesday this week. Thanks so much for sharing it! :)

Eva {Tales of the Scotts} said...

Wow, I can't stand cream cheese but this looks DELISH!!

Jill @Two Yellow Birds Decor said...

I know I have commented on this before, but I just wanted to let you know I am featuring your amazing pie at today's link party! WHAOO!!

Motivated Mommy of two said...

Your recipe looks delicious, this is something that I am going to have to try.I have a sweet tooth :).
Visiting from the two yellow birds decor link party. Congrats on being featured

Kim @ The Sasse Life said...

Yummmm! You were featured!

Anonymous said...

This pie is so easy and truly delish! It tastes much more complicated than it is. Shhh... Taking this to our family Fourth of July pie contest tomorrow. Wish me luck!

Post a Comment

Blogging tips